1. General:
Water for potable and fire protection use is provided by a piping
distribution system constructed of transite pipe. The water from the
system is supplied from two well pumps, one located at the intersection of
Central & Cranberry Walks (Pumphouse #1). and the second on Bay Walk
opposite the Old Fire House (Pumphouse #2).
The system is normally pressurized to approximately 60 pounds per square
inch (PSI) by a 5,000 gallon hydro-pneumatic tank located adjacent to
Pumphouse #1.
2. Pump #1:
Pump #1 is an electrically driven, vertical, well pump which can also be
powered by a gasoline driven engine. The engine is under the
administrative control of the Brentwood Water District. In order to
activate the engine during a power failure, Brentwood Water must be
notified to send a technician from the mainland. It is estimated that this
will take a minimum of one hour. Although this pump has a larger flow
capability, it is throttled to a maximum flow rate of approximately 275
gallons per minute (GPM), which is the maximum capability of the water
treatment system, to provide proper treatment for health and safety of the
public.
3. Pump #2:
Rump #2 is an electrically driven, vertical, well pump without any
emergency backup. The pump is throttled to approximately 185 GPM for water
treatment purposes.
Pump #2 is automatically activated when system demand cannot be maintained
by Pump #1
4. Hydro-pneumatic Tank:
The water mains are pressurized by the use of compressed air in the hydro
pneumatic tank. The 5000 gallon tank contains approximately 31000 litres
of water with compressed air above the water level at a nominal pressure
of 60 psi. The compressor is electrically powered without an emergency
backup. During a power failure, the system will become depressurized when
the water in the tank is expended.
Brentwood Water District will not permit the system to be operated at
the capacities greater than the current throttling settings. If operated
at larger flow rates, contamination of the system will occur, which will
cause its shut down for potable water purposes until the entire system is
flushed and drained.
5. Distribution Piping:
The distribution piping is constructed of transite [cement asbestos). The
mains along Central Walk, portions of Bay Walk, and Broadway are six inch
diameter (6") with branch lines of smaller diameter in varying sizes.
Hydraulically speaking. a 6" diameter pipe has a maximum flaw capability
of 500 to 600 GPM for standard design velocities and pressure drops. If,
for instance, it was attempted to pump 1,000 GPM through a 8" pipe, the
velocity would be 11.3 ft/sec with a pressure drop of approximately 6.0
psi per hundred feet of pipe. At a pumping rate of 1,000 GPM, the total
pressure loss between Pump #1 and the eastern end of Dunewood would be 60
psi, which is the total pressure available. In layman's terms, this means
that the maximum capacity of the system is approximately the capacity of
the two throttled pumps (460 GPM).
6. Potable Water:
The system capability based upon pump settings and water treatment
capability is approximately 460 GPM. Potable water use draws water from
multiple locations with flow rates averaged out to the various mains and
branches. Potable water is theoretically available for a maximum of 6 to
10 minutes in the event of a power failure. Experience has shown, however,
that pressure is lost almost immediately in the entire system in the event
of a power failure.
7. Water for Fire Protection:
During an electrical power failure situation, no water is available from
the public water supply system in Fair Harbor.
Recent testing by the Fair Harbor Fire Department has demonstrated that
when one pumper is connected to a hydrant and operated over 200 GPM, the
system cannot meet this minimal demand after only a few minutes, and the
suction lines draw a vacuum (become depressurized).
When two pumpers are connected to separate hydrants at remote
locations, the system becomes depressurized almost immediately with almost
total loss of fire fighting capability.
8. Interconnections:
The Fair Harbor water supply system is connected on the western side with
the Saltaire system by means of a manually activated valve. On the eastern
side, it is connected to the Suffolk water supply system also by a
manually activated valve.
Since water from the Suffolk County system is also supplied by
electrically driven pumps, water is not available in the event of a power
failure from the eastern interconnect. The two wells in Saltaire do have
emergency generator backup and can supply nominal amounts of water to Fair
Harbor through the interconnect valve in the event of a power failure.
9. Conclusions:
The current public water supply system has limited potential to supply
sufficient water for fire fighting purposes. Even with interconnection to
adjacent systems [Saltaire on the western side and Suffolk County on the
eastern side), the six inch diameter mains produce a pressure drop of
approximately 2 psi per hundred feet of main at 500 GPM excluding pressure
loss through fittings and valves. Thus, even with an interconnection open,
the pressure and flows available are severely restricted (Estimated at 300
GPM total available). This was vividly demonstrated during the January 3,
1999 fire in Saltaire when only one pumper could operate efficiently
although multiple pumpers were on the scene.
Based on the above, it is concluded that alternate water sources are
required in order to provide adequate
fire protection in
Fair Harbor.
Informal discussion of the Fair Harbor Water System by
Neil Rudikoff, Fire Commissioner (10/1999) |